This ranking is based on an algorithm that combines various factors, including the votes of our users and search trends on the internet.

List of Alyson Hannigan Movies: Ranked Best To Worst

1. American Pie (1999)
44
18
American Pie
R
44
18

A teen sex comedy film, American Pie focuses on a group of best friends studying in East Great Falls High School who make a pact to lose their virginity before their high school graduation. The film became a hit at the box office and spawned three direct sequels. 

Role:
Michelle Flaherty
Directed By:
Paul Weitz, Chris Weitz
2. American Reunion (2012)
26
12
American Reunion
R
26
12

The fourth film of the American Pie series, American Reunion is about the high school reunion of lifelong friends who return after a decade to their hometown, East Great Falls, Michigan. Jim and Michelle are married with a son, while Kevin-Vicky and Oz-Heather have parted ways. But along with Finch, Stifler and others, they all meet again to spend a reunion weekend together. 

Role:
Michelle
Directed By:
Jon Hurwitz, Hayden Schlossberg
3. American Pie 2 (2001)
28
14
American Pie 2
R
28
14

The sequel to the 1999 sex-comedy American Pie, follows the sexual adventures of the five friends Jim, Kevin, Oz, Finch, and Stifler. In the midst of their misadventures, Jim finds his true love in Michelle, and Finch ends up with Stifler’s mom.  

Role:
Michelle Flaherty
Directed By:
J.B. Rogers
4. American Wedding (2003)
24
13
American Wedding
R
24
13

The third installment in the American Pie series focuses on Jim Levenstein and Michelle Flaherty’s marriage. While Jim asks his best friends Kevin and Paul to ensure everything goes smoothly, Stifler arrives to cause sufficient mayhem with his attempts to win Cadence’s heart, teaching Jim to dance, and organizing a bachelor party. 

Role:
Michelle Flaherty
Starring:
January Jones, Fred Willard, Eugene Levy, Jennifer Coolidge, Jason Biggs, Seann William Scott, Eddie Kaye Thomas
Directed By:
Jesse Dylan
5. Flora & Ulysses (2021)
8
4
Flora & Ulysses
PG
8
4
Role:
Phyllis
6. Dead Man on Campus (1998)
8
5
Dead Man on Campus
R
8
5
Starring:
Mark-Paul Gosselaar, Lochlyn Munro, Tom Everett Scott, Poppy Montgomery
Directed By:
Alan Cohn
7. You Might Be the Killer (2018)
7
4
You Might Be the Killer
TV-MA
7
4
Role:
Chuck
Starring:
Keith David, Fran Kranz, Brittany S. Hall , Jenna Harvey
Directed By:
Brett Simmons
8. Boys and Girls (2000)
7
5
Boys and Girls
PG-13
7
5

Boys and Girls is a romantic comedy film which tells the story of Jennifer and Ryan, who become best friends. However, their relationship becomes quite complicated after they end up having sex with each other.

Starring:
Claire Forlani, Brendon Ryan Barrett, Freddie Prinze Jr., Gay Thomas Wilson
Directed By:
Robert Iscove
9. My Stepmother Is an Alien (1988)
7
5
My Stepmother Is an Alien
PG-13
7
5

When widower astrophysicist Steven Mills accidently sends out energy waves destroying a planet’s gravity, they send an attractive extraterrestrial, Celeste, to investigate and reverse the effects of his research. Instead, she finds herself enjoying her life with Steve and his daughter, Jesse. As she experiences emotions and feelings like love for the first time, Celeste is reluctant to return to her home-planet.

Role:
Jessie Mills
Directed By:
Richard Benjamin
11. Kim Possible (2019)
3
4
Kim Possible
TV-G
3
4
Role:
Dr. Ann Possible
Starring:
Patton Oswalt, Todd Stashwick, Sean Giambrone, Ciara Wilson
Directed By:
Zach Lipovsky, Adam B. Stein
12. Date Movie (2006)
5
8
Date Movie
5
8

This 2006 romantic comedy film is about an obese woman Julia, who believes that she will never find the love of her life, due to her body. Later, she develops a crush on a guy named Grant, but they have to face several challenges before they eventually unite. 

Role:
Julia Jones
Starring:
Carmen Electra, Sophie Monk, Jennifer Coolidge, Fred Willard, Adam Campbell, Eddie Griffin
Directed By:
Aaron Seltzer, Jason Friedberg
13. In the Game (2004)
9
3
In the Game
9
3
Starring:
Sara Gilbert, Christine Baranski, Jennifer Love Hewitt, Josie Davis, Paula Cale, Dennis Cruzado
Directed By:
James Widdoes
14. Switched at Birth (1991)
8
3
Switched at Birth
PG
8
3
Starring:
Bonnie Bedelia, Ed Asner, Edward Asner, Brian Kerwin, John M. Jackson
Directed By:
Waris Hussein
15. The First Wives Club (2016)
8
4
The First Wives Club
8
4
Role:
Maggie
Starring:
Vanessa Lachey, Megan Hilty, Christian Ochoa, Adam Dorsey
Directed By:
Betty Thomas
16. A Case for Life (1996)
7
4
A Case for Life
7
4
Starring:
Valerie Bertinelli, Vincent Berry, Larry Cedar, William Bumiller, Gregg Almquist
Directed By:
Eric Laneuville
17. The Stranger Beside Me (1995)
7
4
The Stranger Beside Me
7
4
Starring:
Tiffani Thiessen, Eric Close, Lorrie Morgan, Steven Eckholdt, Casey Sander
Directed By:
Sandor Stern
18. Do You Take This Man (2016)
7
4
Do You Take This Man
7
4
Role:
Rachael
Starring:
Alona Tal, Mackenzie Astin, Anthony Rapp, Thomas Dekker, Jonathan Bennett
Directed By:
Joshua Tunick
19. For My Daughter's Honor (1996)
7
4
For My Daughter's Honor
7
4
Role:
Kelly
Starring:
Gary Cole, Mary Kay Place, Mac Davis, Nicholle Tom
Directed By:
Alan Metzger
20. Americana (2004)
6
4
Americana
6
4
Role:
Andrea
Starring:
Michael Landes, Colin Ferguson, Joanna Canton, Claire Coffee
Directed By:
21. Impure Thoughts (1985)
6
4
Impure Thoughts
PG
6
4
Starring:
Judith Anderson, Brad Dourif, John Putch, Terry Beaver
Directed By:
Michael A. Simpson
22. More Time with Family (2014)
6
4
More Time with Family
6
4
Role:
Cindy Rizzo
Starring:
Joe Pantoliano, Taylor John Smith, Nancy Lenehan, Missy Doty
Directed By:
James Burrows
23. Hayley Wagner, Star (1999)
5
4
Hayley Wagner, Star
5
4
Starring:
Penn Jillette, Pam Grier, Priscilla Presley, Bill Fagerbakke, Meghan Ory
Directed By:
Nell Scovell
24. Beyond the City Limits (2001)
3
4
Beyond the City Limits
R
3
4
Role:
Lexi
Starring:
Nastassja Kinski, Jennifer Esposito, Brian George, Brian McCardie
Directed By:
Gigi Gaston

Animation Movies

The Simpsons
40
6
The Simpsons
TV-14
40
6
Starring:
Liam Neeson, Kristen Bell, Martin Short, Jane Lynch, Bill Hader, Sacha Baron Cohen, Channing Tatum
Directed By:
Robot Chicken
11
3
Robot Chicken
TV-MA
11
3
Starring:
Allison Janney, Amy Brenneman, Whoopi Goldberg, Maisie Williams, Macaulay Culkin, Sarah Wayne Callies, Danai Gurira
Directed By:
Rugrats
10
3
Rugrats
TV-G
10
3
Starring:
Jeremy Sisto, Drake Bell, Ron Leibman, Kenan Thompson, Adam West, Busta Rhymes, Tara Strong
Directed By:
Jim Duffy, Jeff Scott, Norton Virgien, Rick Bugental, John Holmquist
American Dad!
15
5
American Dad!
TV-14
15
5
Starring:
Danny Glover, Rosie O'Donnell, Katharine Ross, Burt Reynolds, Laura Prepon, Sandra Oh, Kyle MacLachlan
Directed By:
King of the Hill
10
4
King of the Hill
TV-14
10
4
Starring:
Christina Applegate, Nathan Fillion, Buddy Ebsen, Chris Rock, William Devane, William H. Macy, John Amos
Directed By:
Wesley Archer, Klay Hall, Tricia Garcia, Kyoung Hee Lim, Adam Kuhlman
Buffy the Vampire Slayer: The Animated Series (2004)
7
3
Buffy the Vampire Slayer: The Animated Series
7
3
Role:
Willow Rosenberg (voice)
Starring:
Nicholas Brendon, Anthony Head, Giselle Loren
Sofia the First
6
3
Sofia the First
TV-Y
6
3
Starring:
Wayne Brady, Josh Gad, Vivica A. Fox, Ariel Winter, Florence Henderson, Ginnifer Goodwin, Melissa Rauch
Directed By:
Jamie Mitchell, Larry Leichliter, Mircea Mantta
The Wild Thornberrys
7
3
The Wild Thornberrys
TV-G
7
3
Starring:
Lynn Redgrave, Swoosie Kurtz, Craig Ferguson, Alfred Molina, Courtney B. Vance, Betty White, Marion Ross
Directed By:
Cathy Malkasian, Sylvia Keulen, Carol Millican, Steve Ressel, Becky Bristow
The Goode Family
5
3
The Goode Family
5
3
Starring:
Brian Doyle-Murray, Bob Odenkirk, Nancy Carell, Mike Judge, Johnny Knoxville, Kevin Nealon, Tara Strong
Directed By:
Seth Kearsley, Anthony Chun, Wesley Archer, John Rice, Jennifer Coyle
Farce of the Penguins (2006)
2
3
Farce of the Penguins
R
2
3

Farce of the Penguins is an animated mockumentary film which revolves around a group of male penguins, who are making a seventy-mile trek to go and meet the female penguins at the breeding grounds. The film was made as a parody of ‘March of the Penguins’, a French feature film.

Role:
Hottie Penguin (voice)
Starring:
Brie Larson, Samuel L. Jackson, Damon Wayans, Abe Vigoda, Tracy Morgan, John Stamos, Dave Coulier
Directed By:
Bob Saget

TV Shows

Veronica Mars
15
2
Veronica Mars
TV-14
15
2
Starring:
Dianna Agron, Aaron Paul, Kevin Smith, Amanda Seyfried, Ed Begley Jr., Paris Hilton, Michael Cera
Directed By:
John T. Kretchmer, Nick Marck, Michael Fields, Harry Winer, Jason Bloom
How I Met Your Mother
49
12
How I Met Your Mother
TV-14
49
12
Role:
Lily Aldrin / ... (208 episodes, 2005-2014)
Starring:
John Lithgow, Courtney Ford, Beth Riesgraf, Heidi Klum, Joe Manganiello, Ashley Benson, Judy Greer
Directed By:
Buffy the Vampire Slayer
20
3
Buffy the Vampire Slayer
TV-14
20
3
Role:
Willow Rosenberg (144 episodes, 1997-2003)
Starring:
Alexandra Breckenridge, Sarah Michelle Gellar, Bianca Lawson, Amy Adams, Joss Whedon, Felicia Day, Kal Penn
Directed By:
That '70s Show
21
4
That '70s Show
TV-PG
21
4
Starring:
Tom Bosley, Roger Daltrey, Ashton Kutcher, Cole Sprouse, Wayne Knight, Tommy Chong, Katey Sagal
Directed By:
David Trainer
Penn & Teller: Fool Us
11
2
Penn & Teller: Fool Us
TV-PG
11
2
Role:
Herself - Hostess (27 episodes, 2016-2018)
Starring:
Penn Jillette, Teller, Jonathan Ross, Richard Bellars
Angel
13
3
Angel
13
3
Starring:
Josh Holloway, Jeffrey Dean Morgan, Summer Glau, Adam Baldwin, Julie Benz, David Boreanaz, Eliza Dushku
Picket Fences
10
2
Picket Fences
10
2
Starring:
Tom Skerritt, Michelle Pfeiffer, Ray Walston, James Coburn, Jack Black, Teresa Wright, Don Cheadle
Directed By:
Almost Home
8
2
Almost Home
8
2
Starring:
Donal Logue, Brittany Murphy, Ben Affleck, Jared Leto, Connie Ray, Olivia Burnette, Lee Norris
Directed By:
Arlene Sanford, Patrick Maloney, Linda Day, David Trainer
Tit for Tat
8
2
Tit for Tat
8
2
Role:
Ally (1 episode, 2009)
Starring:
Emily Deschanel, Minka Kelly, Katharine McPhee, Jaime King, Emily Deschanel
Directed By:
Steve Carr
Roseanne
9
3
Roseanne
TV-PG
9
3
Starring:
Joseph Gordon-Levitt, Joan Collins, Alexis Arquette, Shelley Winters, Bill Maher, Tobey Maguire, Dina Merrill
Directed By:
100 Deeds for Eddie McDowd
7
3
100 Deeds for Eddie McDowd
7
3
Starring:
Tim Curry, Ashley Tisdale, Brenda Song, Seth Green, Aaron Paul, William Francis McGuire
Directed By:
Free Spirit
6
3
Free Spirit
6
3
Role:
Jessie Harper (14 episodes, 1989-1990)
Starring:
Robert Reed, Seth Green, Florence Henderson, Dave Coulier, Corinne Bohrer, Franc Luz
Directed By:
Art Dielhenn
The McCarthys
6
3
The McCarthys
6
3
Starring:
Rick Fox, Jean Smart, Laurie Metcalf, John Ratzenberger, Jane Kaczmarek, Jack McGee, Joey McIntyre
Directed By:
Touched by an Angel
6
3
Touched by an Angel
TV-G
6
3
Starring:
Alanna Ubach, Sarah Hyland, Linda Lavin, Mary Elizabeth Winstead, Ann-Margret, Richard Chamberlain, Christina Pickles
Directed By:
Peter H. Hunt, Timothy Van Patten, Victor Lobl, Bethany Rooney, Stuart Margolin

Alyson Hannigan Awards

People's Choice Awards
Winner Favorite TV Comedy Actress 2010