This ranking is based on an algorithm that combines various factors, including the votes of our users and search trends on the internet.

List of Alyson Hannigan Movies: Ranked Best To Worst

1. American Pie (1999)
15
3
American Pie
R
15
3

A teen sex comedy film, American Pie focuses on a group of best friends studying in East Great Falls High School who make a pact to lose their virginity before their high school graduation. The film became a hit at the box office and spawned three direct sequels. 

As:
Cast
Role:
Michelle Flaherty
Director:
Paul Weitz, Chris Weitz
Genres:
Comedy
2. American Reunion (2012)
15
3
American Reunion
R
15
3

The fourth film of the American Pie series, American Reunion is about the high school reunion of lifelong friends who return after a decade to their hometown, East Great Falls, Michigan. Jim and Michelle are married with a son, while Kevin-Vicky and Oz-Heather have parted ways. But along with Finch, Stifler and others, they all meet again to spend a reunion weekend together. 

As:
Cast
Role:
Michelle
Director:
Jon Hurwitz, Hayden Schlossberg
Genres:
Comedy
3. American Pie 2 (2001)
14
4
American Pie 2
R
14
4

The sequel to the 1999 sex-comedy American Pie, follows the sexual adventures of the five friends Jim, Kevin, Oz, Finch, and Stifler. In the midst of their misadventures, Jim finds his true love in Michelle, and Finch ends up with Stifler’s mom.  

As:
Cast
Role:
Michelle Flaherty
Director:
J.B. Rogers
Genres:
Comedy
4. American Wedding (2003)
13
3
American Wedding
R
13
3

The third installment in the American Pie series focuses on Jim Levenstein and Michelle Flaherty’s marriage. While Jim asks his best friends Kevin and Paul to ensure everything goes smoothly, Stifler arrives to cause sufficient mayhem with his attempts to win Cadence’s heart, teaching Jim to dance, and organizing a bachelor party. 

As:
Cast
Role:
Michelle Flaherty
Director:
Jesse Dylan
Genres:
Comedy, Romance
Star Cast:
January Jones, Fred Willard, Eugene Levy, Jennifer Coolidge, Jason Biggs, Seann William Scott, Eddie Kaye Thomas
5. Flora & Ulysses (2021)
8
2
Flora & Ulysses
PG
8
2
As:
Cast
Role:
Phyllis
Genres:
Adventure, Comedy, Family
6. Dead Man on Campus (1998)
10
3
Dead Man on Campus
R
10
3
As:
Cast
Director:
Alan Cohn
Genres:
Comedy
Star Cast:
Mark-Paul Gosselaar, Lochlyn Munro, Tom Everett Scott, Poppy Montgomery
7. You Might Be the Killer (2018)
10
3
You Might Be the Killer
TV-MA
10
3
As:
Cast
Role:
Chuck
Director:
Brett Simmons
Genres:
Comedy, Horror, Mystery
Star Cast:
Keith David, Fran Kranz, Brittany S. Hall , Jenna Harvey
8. Boys and Girls (2000)
9
2
Boys and Girls
PG-13
9
2

Boys and Girls is a romantic comedy film which tells the story of Jennifer and Ryan, who become best friends. However, their relationship becomes quite complicated after they end up having sex with each other.

As:
Cast
Director:
Robert Iscove
Genres:
Comedy, Romance, Drama
Star Cast:
Claire Forlani, Brendon Ryan Barrett, Freddie Prinze Jr., Gay Thomas Wilson
11. Kim Possible (2019)
6
1
Kim Possible
TV-G
6
1
As:
Cast
Role:
Dr. Ann Possible
Director:
Zach Lipovsky, Adam B. Stein
Genres:
Action, Adventure, Comedy
Star Cast:
Patton Oswalt, Todd Stashwick, Sean Giambrone, Ciara Wilson
12. Date Movie (2006)
7
2
Date Movie
7
2

This 2006 romantic comedy film is about an obese woman Julia, who believes that she will never find the love of her life, due to her body. Later, she develops a crush on a guy named Grant, but they have to face several challenges before they eventually unite. 

As:
Cast
Role:
Julia Jones
Director:
Aaron Seltzer, Jason Friedberg
Genres:
Comedy, Romance
Star Cast:
Carmen Electra, Jennifer Coolidge, Fred Willard, Adam Campbell, Sophie Monk, Eddie Griffin
13. Impure Thoughts (1985)
10
3
Impure Thoughts
PG
10
3
As:
Cast
Director:
Michael A. Simpson
Genres:
Comedy
Star Cast:
Judith Anderson, Brad Dourif, John Putch, Terry Beaver
14. Do You Take This Man (2016)
9
2
Do You Take This Man
9
2
As:
Cast
Role:
Rachael
Director:
Joshua Tunick
Genres:
Drama
Star Cast:
Mackenzie Astin, Anthony Rapp, Thomas Dekker, Jonathan Bennett
15. Beyond the City Limits (2001)
7
2
Beyond the City Limits
R
7
2
As:
Cast
Role:
Lexi
Director:
Gigi Gaston
Genres:
Drama, Crime
Star Cast:
Nastassja Kinski, Jennifer Esposito, Brian George, Brian McCardie

TV Movie(s)

2. Switched at Birth (1991)
11
3
Switched at Birth
PG
11
3
As:
Cast
Director:
Waris Hussein
Genres:
Drama
Star Cast:
Bonnie Bedelia, Ed Asner, Edward Asner, Brian Kerwin, John M. Jackson
3. More Time with Family (2014)
11
3
More Time with Family
11
3
As:
Cast
Role:
Cindy Rizzo
Director:
James Burrows
Genres:
Comedy
Star Cast:
Joe Pantoliano, Taylor John Smith, Nancy Lenehan, Missy Doty
4. A Case for Life (1996)
12
3
A Case for Life
12
3
As:
Cast
Director:
Eric Laneuville
Genres:
Drama
Star Cast:
Valerie Bertinelli, Vincent Berry, Larry Cedar, William Bumiller, Gregg Almquist
5. The Stranger Beside Me (1995)
10
3
The Stranger Beside Me
10
3
As:
Cast
Director:
Sandor Stern
Genres:
Drama
Star Cast:
Tiffani Thiessen, Eric Close, Lorrie Morgan, Steven Eckholdt, Casey Sander
6. For My Daughter's Honor (1996)
10
3
For My Daughter's Honor
10
3
As:
Cast
Role:
Kelly
Director:
Alan Metzger
Genres:
Drama
Star Cast:
Gary Cole, Mary Kay Place, Mac Davis, Nicholle Tom
7. The First Wives Club (2016)
9
2
The First Wives Club
9
2
As:
Cast
Role:
Maggie
Director:
Betty Thomas
Genres:
Comedy
Star Cast:
Vanessa Lachey, Megan Hilty, Christian Ochoa, Adam Dorsey
8. Americana (2004)
8
2
Americana
8
2
As:
Cast
Role:
Andrea
Director:
David Schwimmer
Genres:
Comedy
Star Cast:
Michael Landes, Colin Ferguson, Joanna Canton, Claire Coffee

Animation(s)

Buffy the Vampire Slayer: The Animated Series (2004)
Buffy the Vampire Slayer: The Animated Series
As:
Cast
Role:
Willow Rosenberg (voice)
Genres:
Animation, Action, Fantasy
Star Cast:
Nicholas Brendon, Anthony Head, Giselle Loren

TV Shows and Videos

Penn & Teller: Fool Us (2011)
Penn & Teller: Fool Us
TV-PG
As:
Cast
Role:
Herself - Hostess (27 episodes, 2016-2018)
Genres:
Game-Show
Star Cast:
Penn Jillette, Teller, Jonathan Ross, Richard Bellars
Free Spirit (1989)
Free Spirit
As:
Cast
Role:
Jessie Harper (14 episodes, 1989-1990)
Director:
Art Dielhenn
Genres:
Comedy
Star Cast:
Robert Reed, Dave Coulier, Seth Green, Corinne Bohrer, Franc Luz
Buffy the Vampire Slayer (2002)
Buffy the Vampire Slayer
T
As:
Cast
Role:
Willow Rosenberg (voice)
Genres:
Fantasy, Action
Star Cast:
David Boreanaz, Charisma Carpenter, Nicholas Brendon, Anthony Head

Alyson Hannigan Awards

People's Choice Awards
Winner Favorite TV Comedy Actress 2010