This ranking is based on an algorithm that combines various factors, including the votes of our users and search trends on the internet.

List of Hayley Mills Movies: Ranked Best To Worst

1. The Trouble with Angels (1966)
58
4
The Trouble with Angels
PG
58
4

A comedy about two lively girls growing up in a Catholic environment. It follows their adventures as they go on making mischief and giving the nuns at their Catholic school a hard time. 

Starring:
Rosalind Russell, Mary Wickes, Binnie Barnes, Camilla Sparv
Directed By:
Ida Lupino
2. The Parent Trap (1961)
53
2
The Parent Trap
TV-G
53
2

Two identical twin sisters, who are separated by birth due to the divorce of their parents, get reunited years later at a summer camp, where they decide to bring their parents back together. Therefore, the girls, switch places with each other, and go back to their parents, and starts working on their plan.

Role:
Susan Evers / Sharon McKendrick
Starring:
Sir John Mills, Brian Keith, John Mills, Charles Ruggles, Una Merkel, Maureen O'Hara
Directed By:
David Swift
3. Pollyanna (1960)
42
2
Pollyanna
42
2

After her parents pass away, a 12 year old girl named Pollyanna goes to live with her Aunt Polly in a town named Harrington. Within some time, she begins to transform the town with her good will and kindness.

Role:
Pollyanna
Starring:
Agnes Moorehead, Jane Wyman, Paul Frees, Karl Malden
Directed By:
David Swift
Awards:
Golden Globe Award for Most Promising Newcomer - Female, Academy Award for
4. Tiger Bay (1959)
35
2
Tiger Bay
35
2
Role:
Gillie
Starring:
Sir John Mills, John Mills, Megs Jenkins, Yvonne Mitchell, Horst Buchholz
Directed By:
J. Lee Thompson
Awards:
BAFTA Award for Most Promising Newcomer to Film
5. The Chalk Garden (1964)
36
3
The Chalk Garden
36
3
Role:
Laurel
Starring:
Deborah Kerr, Sir John Mills, John Mills, Felix Aylmer, Edith Evans
Directed By:
Ronald Neame
6. Whistle Down the Wind (1961)
33
5
Whistle Down the Wind
33
5
Starring:
Norman Bird, Bernard Lee, Alan Bates, Diane Clare
Directed By:
Bryan Forbes
7. The Moon-Spinners (1964)
37
3
The Moon-Spinners
G
37
3
Role:
Nicky Ferris
Starring:
Eli Wallach, Irene Papas, Joan Greenwood, Peter McEnery
Directed By:
James Neilson
8. The Family Way (1966)
25
5
The Family Way
25
5
Role:
Jenny Piper
Starring:
Lynn Redgrave, Sir John Mills, John Mills, Wilfred Pickles, Avril Angers, John Comer
Directed By:
Roy Boulting, John Boulting
9. Summer Magic (1963)
31
4
Summer Magic
31
4
Role:
Nancy Carey
Starring:
Dorothy McGuire, Una Merkel, Burl Ives, Deborah Walley
Directed By:
James Neilson
10. The Truth About Spring (1965)
30
2
The Truth About Spring
30
2

The Truth about Spring is an adventure comedy drama film which tells the story of a young girl Spring, who lives a simple and isolated life with her father. However, she sets out on an adventure in search of a buried treasure.

Role:
Spring Tyler
Starring:
Sir John Mills, John Mills, Harry Andrews, Lionel Jeffries, James MacArthur
Directed By:
Richard Thorpe
11. That Darn Cat! (1965)
33
3
That Darn Cat!
33
3

That Darn Cat! is a comedy thriller film which tells the story of a kidnapped woman, who tries to send out an SOS message with the help of a wandering cat. Upon learning about this, the cat’s owner decides to inform the FBI. The FBI tries to follow the cat, hoping that it will lead them to the kidnapped woman.

Role:
Patti Randall
Starring:
Elsa Lanchester, Roddy McDowall, Neville Brand, Dean Jones
Directed By:
Robert Stevenson
12. Gypsy Girl (1966)
23
3
Gypsy Girl
23
3

This romantic drama film revolves around a girl who is blamed for an accident in which her friend was killed. She is neglected by society, but years later, she finds romance in a gypsy boy, who falls for her.

Role:
Brydie White
Starring:
Ian McShane, Geoffrey Bayldon, Laurence Naismith, Annette Crosbie
Directed By:
13. Take a Girl Like You (1969)
18
4
Take a Girl Like You
R
18
4
Role:
Jenny
Starring:
Oliver Reed, Sheila Hancock, Noel Harrison, John Bird
Directed By:
Jonathan Miller
14. In Search of the Castaways (1962)
28
3
In Search of the Castaways
28
3
Role:
Mary Grant
Starring:
Joss Ackland, Maurice Chevalier, George Sanders, Wilfrid Hyde-White
Directed By:
Robert Stevenson
15. Twisted Nerve (1968)
17
3
Twisted Nerve
17
3
Role:
Susan Harper
Starring:
Phyllis Calvert, Billie Whitelaw, Barry Foster, Hywel Bennett
Directed By:
Roy Boulting
16. Mr. Forbush and the Penguins (1971)
16
3
Mr. Forbush and the Penguins
16
3

Richard Forbush, a young London biologist, is more interested in girls than science. When assigned to study penguins’ colony in Antarctica, he reluctantly agrees only impress his latest fascination, Tara St. John Luke, a biology student. However, while studying the penguins, he truly becomes interested and tries for their betterment. When it is time to return, Forbush is a completely changed person. 

Role:
Tara St. John Luke
Starring:
John Hurt, Joss Ackland, Thorley Walters, Dudley Sutton, Tony Britton
Directed By:
Roy Boulting, Alfred Viola
17. So Well Remembered (1947)
13
2
So Well Remembered
13
2

So Well Remembered is a drama film which tells the story of George Boswell, a town councilor and newspaper editor, who at the end of the Second World War, starts to recall the past twenty six years of his life in his hometown. He remembers how as a councilor and newspaper editor, he had fought for better living and working conditions for the people.

Role:
Infant (uncredited)
Starring:
Trevor Howard, Sir John Mills, John Mills, Richard Carlson, Martha Scott, Patricia Roc
Directed By:
Edward Dmytryk
18. A Matter of Innocence (1967)
18
3
A Matter of Innocence
18
3

Polly Barlow sees the world for the first time after she decides to spend some time with her wealthy aunt as a traveling companion. While in India, her aunt passes away, leaving her alone. She soon starts having a romance with a local tour boy.

Role:
Polly Barlow
Starring:
Shashi Kapoor, Trevor Howard, Brenda de Banzie, Dorothy Alison
Directed By:
Guy Green
19. Deadly Strangers (1975)
18
2
Deadly Strangers
R
18
2
Role:
Belle Adams
Starring:
Peter Jeffrey, Sterling Hayden, Simon Ward, Ken Hutchison
Directed By:
Sidney Hayers
20. Endless Night (1972)
19
2
Endless Night
19
2
Role:
Ellie Thomsen
Starring:
Britt Ekland, Lois Maxwell, George Sanders, Hywel Bennett
Directed By:
Sidney Gilliat
21. Foster (2011)
11
3
Foster
PG
11
3
Starring:
Toni Collette, Ioan Gruffudd, Richard E. Grant, Anne Reid
Directed By:
Jonathan Newman
22. Appointment with Death (1988)
13
3
Appointment with Death
PG
13
3
Starring:
Lauren Bacall, John Gielgud, Carrie Fisher, Peter Ustinov, Piper Laurie
Directed By:
Michael Winner
23. Africa: Texas Style (1967)
10
3
Africa: Texas Style
10
3

Africa Texas Style is an adventure Western film which tells the story of an American cowboy Jim Sinclair, who travels all the way to Africa, to look after an estate owned by Howard Hayes. Although Hayes hopes that his efforts will help to feed starving people in the nearby villages, another rancher named Karl has other ideas.

Starring:
Sir John Mills, John Mills, Hugh O'Brian, Adrienne Corri, Nigel Green
Directed By:
Andrew Marton
24. The Kingfisher Caper (1975)
12
2
The Kingfisher Caper
12
2

Benedict and his sister Tracey are the offsprings of Hendrich Van Der Byl, who owns and operates Van Der Byl Diamond Mines, a lucrative diamond mining operation in South Africa. Benedict spends most of his time pursuing women, and also steals a diamond here and there occasionally, for his female companions. His life gets complicated when an outsider named Johnny, who has overshadowed Benedict all his life, tries to take control of their business empire. Things get complicated for Benedict because Tracey decides to side with Johnny. 

Role:
Tracey Van Der Byl
Starring:
David McCallum, Jon Cypher, Barry Trengove, Volenté Bertotti
Directed By:
Dirk de Villiers
25. The Bananas Boat (1976)
9
1
The Bananas Boat
9
1
Role:
Jenny
Starring:
Lionel Jeffries, Warren Mitchell, Doug McClure, Alberto de Mendoza
Directed By:
Sidney Hayers
26. Stricken (2005)
14
2
Stricken
14
2
Role:
Hildy
Starring:
Denver Andre, Tiffany Bartok, Joe Lo Truglio, Joe Narciso
Directed By:
Jayce Bartok, Christopher J. Scott
27. After Midnight (1990)
10
2
After Midnight
10
2
Role:
Sally Ryan
Starring:
Vladek Sheybal, Saeed Jaffrey, Ian Dury, Dhirendra
Directed By:
Shani Grewal
28. Mandie and the Cherokee Treasure (2010)
9
3
Mandie and the Cherokee Treasure
G
9
3
Role:
Mary Elizabeth Taft
Starring:
Lexi Johnson, William Yelton, Amanda Waters, Terrell Anthony
Directed By:
Joy Chapman
29. 2BPerfectlyHonest (2004)
8
1
2BPerfectlyHonest
R
8
1
Starring:
Andrew McCarthy, Aida Turturro, John Turturro, Adam Trese
Directed By:
Randel Cole

TV Movie(s)

1. The Parent Trap II (1986)
16
3
The Parent Trap II
16
3
Role:
Susan Carey / Sharon Ferris
Starring:
Tom Skerritt, Alex Harvey, Bridgette Andersen, Carrie Kei Heim
Directed By:
Ron Maxwell
2. Back Home (1989)
15
2
Back Home
15
2
Role:
Mrs. Peggy Dickinson
Starring:
Jean Anderson, Brenda Bruce, Hayley Carr, Adam Stevenson
Directed By:
Piers Haggard
3. Child Stars: Their Story (2000)
14
2
Child Stars: Their Story
14
2
Role:
Narrator
Starring:
Veronica Cartwright, Angela Cartwright, Baby Peggy, Jeannie Russell
Directed By:
Tony Dow, Melissa Gilbert
4. Parent Trap III (1989)
15
3
Parent Trap III
15
3
Role:
Susan Evers / Sharon Grand
Starring:
Barry Bostwick, Chris Gartin, Ray Baker, Patricia Richardson
Directed By:
Mollie Miller
5. Parent Trap: Hawaiian Honeymoon (1989)
14
3
Parent Trap: Hawaiian Honeymoon
14
3
Role:
Susan Wyatt / Sharon Evers
Starring:
Glenn Shadix, Barry Bostwick, Joy Creel, Leanna Creel
Directed By:
Mollie Miller

Animation(s)

Grimm's Fairy Tales and Storybook Series (1984)
Grimm's Fairy Tales and Storybook Series
Role:
(unknown episodes)
Starring:
June Foray
Amazing Stories (1985)
Amazing Stories
PG-13
Starring:
Christina Applegate, Timothy Francis Robbins, Sid Caesar, Charles Durning, James Cromwell, Harvey Keitel, John Lithgow
Directed By:
Clint Eastwood, Steven Spielberg, Lesli Linka Glatter, Phil Joanou, Paul Bartel
Disney Sing-Along-Songs: Friend Like Me (1993)
Disney Sing-Along-Songs: Friend Like Me
Role:
Sharon / Susan (archiveFootage)
Starring:
Lea Salonga, Corey Burton, Jodi Benson, Wayne Allwine
The Daydreamer (1966)
The Daydreamer
Plot:

A teen boy named Hans Christian Andersen, who is the son of a poor shoemaker, spends his time in daydreams instead of studying at school. Eventually, he runs away from home, and whenever he goes into sleep, he starts dreaming of strange adventures.

Starring:
Victor Borge, Sessue Hayakawa, Tallulah Bankhead, Patty Duke
Directed By:
Jules Bass
A Troll in Central Park (1994)
A Troll in Central Park
G
Plot:

Stanley, a troll is banished by an evil Queen, and he is to serve his exile in New York City. His vessel lands in Central Park, where he meets and befriends two siblings.

Role:
Hillary (voice)
Starring:
Cloris Leachman, Jonathan Pryce, Charles Nelson Reilly, Dom DeLuise
Directed By:
Don Bluth, Gary Goldman

TV Shows and Videos

Thriller (1973)
Thriller
Starring:
Carroll Baker, Helen Mirren, Barbara Feldon, Bob Hoskins, Diane Cilento, Brian Blessed, George Chakiris
Tales of the Unexpected (1979)
Tales of the Unexpected
Starring:
Ian Holm, Katy Jurado, Elaine Stritch, Chaim Topol, Tom Bosley, Dina Merrill, Ed Begley Jr.
Directed By:
Leo Penn, Ray Danton, John Peyser, Barry Davis, Simon Langton
Midsomer Murders (1997)
Midsomer Murders
Starring:
Orlando Bloom, Richard Todd, Phyllis Logan, Mark Gatiss, Pam Ferris, Stephen Moyer, Suzi Quatro
Directed By:
Renny Rye, Peter Smith, Richard Holthouse, Sarah Hellings, Jeremy Silberston
Moving On (2009)
Moving On
Starring:
Johnny Vegas, Corin Redgrave, Jason Manford, Hannah Gordon, Paul Rhys
Directed By:
Johnny Vegas
Murder, She Wrote (1984)
Murder, She Wrote
Starring:
Audra Lindley, Abe Vigoda, Adam West, Bill Maher, Joseph Gordon-Levitt, George Clooney, Janet Leigh
Directed By:
Anthony Pullen Shaw, Walter Grauman, Vincent McEveety, Seymour Robbie, Jerry Jameson
Wild at Heart (2006)
Wild at Heart
Starring:
Amanda Holden, Stephen Tompkinson, Deon Stewardson, Nomsa Xaba
Good Morning, Miss Bliss (1987)
Good Morning, Miss Bliss
TV-G
Role:
Miss Carrie Bliss (14 episodes, 1987-1989)
Starring:
Brian Austin Green, Jonathan Brandis, Carla Gugino, Mark-Paul Gosselaar, Dennis Haskins, Dustin Diamond
Directed By:
Burt Brinckerhoff, Gary Shimokawa
The Love Boat (1977)
The Love Boat
TV-G
Starring:
Andy Griffith, Corey Feldman, Michael J. Fox, Andy Warhol, Tom Hanks, Debbie Reynolds, Jamie Lee Curtis
Directed By:
Richard Kinon, Roger Duchowny, Robert Scheerer, Allen Baron, Ted Lange

Hayley Mills Awards

Golden Globe Awards
Pollyanna Most Promising Newcomer - Female 1961
BAFTA Awards
Tiger Bay Most Promising Newcomer to Film 1960